Gluten-Free Crumbl Sugar Cookies Copycat (2024)

These Gluten-Free Crumbl Sugar Cookies are a copycat recipe of Crumbl Cookies' signature cookie. These giant sugar cookies are soft and buttery, topped with a swirl of almond flavored buttercream frosting in the iconic pink color!

Why You'll Love This Recipe

Crumbl sugar cookies are going viral on social media these days! I first saw these giant cookies on Tiktok and was mesmerized by their videos! The slow motion, often gooey action shots sure do make you want one of their delicious cookies!

Crumbl is a trendy Utah-based bakery that specializes in giant cookies. Each week they have a new menu with a mix of old and new cookie flavors. Their signature cookie is a pink sugar cookie topped with almond flavored buttercream, which they serve chilled.

Crumbl states they do not have any plans to create gluten-free cookies so if we want to join the fun, we will have to make our own!

If you know me, you know I love a good copycat recipe! I've made gluten-free Cheez-its crackers, gluten-free Hawaiian Rolls, and even a gluten-free broccoli cheddar soup that's better than Panera! So when I saw these delicious looking cookies, I knew I had to try and recreate them!

This gluten-free crumbl sugar cookie recipe is so easy to make and requires no chill time! It features a no-roll, drop style sugar cookie that is tender and buttery. You can whip up the cookie dough in about 15 minutes. The pink almond icing is quick and easy to whip up, too!

These decadent cookies are pretty huge! You can make them smaller if you prefer, but the size is part of what makes them fun! Serve them chilled, just like Crumbl, or leave them at room temp for even more softness! Also, be sure to check out my other Crumbl recipes: Gluten-free Galaxy Brownie Cookies and Gluten-free Oreo Dirt Cookies!

Ingredients

• Gluten-Free Flour Blend: This recipe has been tested with King Arthur Measure for Measure and Namaste Perfect Flour Blend
• Powdered Sugar: Don't be alarmed when you see powdered sugar in the ingredients list for the cookies, yes the cookies! Using powdered sugar aids in achieving the tender, soft, melt-in-your mouth quality these cookies have.
• Butter and Oil: Again, it's not often you see oil in a cookie recipe but using a combination of oil and butter gives these cookies the moisture they need to stay soft and tender for days! I have not yet tested these with dairy-free alternatives, please leave a comment if you've tried it!
• Egg: I have yet to try this recipe with an egg replacer so I currently do not have an egg-free recommendation.
• Vanilla and Almond Extract: Almond extract provides this cookie their distinct flavor. If you know you don't like that flavor, substitute with vanilla extract. If you love almond flavor, you can increase the amount just a tiny bit if you wish!
• Cream of Tartar: Don't skip this ingredient. Find it in the spice aisle. It aids in leavening and lends a slight tang to the cookies.
• Pink Gel Food Coloring: The classic Crumbl cookie is pink, but feel free to make them whatever color you want! You can omit the food coloring all together, if desired.

Step By Step

1. Start by mixing the dough in a stand mixer. It's a simple process of creaming the sugars with the butter. Adding the remaining wet ingredients and beating until fluffy. Then incorporate the flour. This whole process is done in just a few minutes resulting in a soft dough.
2. Next, scoop out ¼ cup portions of dough. This is a lot larger than the normal tablespoon-sized cookies you're probably used to making!
3. Place the dough spaced a couple inches apart on parchment lined cookie sheets. You can fit about 6 or 7 on a regular sized cookie sheet. The cookies will spread a bit so don't put more than that on a pan. Press the dough down slightly with your hand. The pressed cookie dough should be between ½ and ¾ inch thickness.
4. Bake the cookies until just cooked through. The tops may be a little crinkled and the bottoms should be light golden brown. Allow them to cool completely on the pan. No need to remove to cooling racks.

1. While the cookies cool, mix up the frosting. This is also quite easy to do! Just cream softened butter together with the powdered sugar. Once combined add in the extracts. Then add in heavy cream 1 tablespoon at a time, mixing well after each addition.
2. Add enough cream to achieve a soft and fluffy icing that is easily spreadable. For me it was about 3 tablespoons of heavy cream.
3. Once cookies are cool, it's time to frost them!
4. Use a small offset spatula or butter knife to place a dollop of icing on the cookie. Spread the icing around the cookie and finish with the classic swirl! You really can't mess this part up, so just have fun!

Storage

Crumble serves these giant cookies chilled. You can serve them chilled or at room temperature. Either way, keep these cookies in an airtight container and consume within 3 days.

You can freeze these cookies as well, even frosted! Wrap tightly and store in the freezer for up to 3 months.

Tips for Success

• Properly measuring the flour is important to the success of this recipe. If you have a kitchen scale, measure the flour by weight. If not, fluff up the flour in your bin. Then spoon flour into the measuring cup and level off the top with a straight edged spatula or knife.
• Substitute at your own risk! Gluten-free baking can be a little tricky. All of the brands and substitutions that I have personally tested in this recipe are listed in the recipe card. Using a different brand's flour blend, single ingredient gluten-free flours, or substituting other ingredients may greatly affect the outcome of this recipe.
• Don't overbake! It is somewhat hard to tell when the cookies are done because they are so pale in color. The bottoms should be light golden brown when done. Err on the side of underbaking rather than overbaking, especially if you love a soft cookie.
• Almond flavor is strong! If you know you don't like the flavor of almond extract, substitute with vanilla! These cookies will still be so delicious! If you love almond flavor, increase the amount of extract in the icing, see the recipe for measurements! If you're in between, just follow the recipe! It has just the right hint of almond flavor that is not too overpowering.

Are there any other Crumbl cookie flavors you want to try? Let me know it in the comments!

Gain access to ourFREEexclusive mini-series:
Gluten-Free Baking and Lessons Learned!
Plus, be the first to know about new recipes and exciting announcements!
📩Sign up for the Mini-Series Here!📩

Recipe

More Gluten-free Cookie Recipes